Is China Overplaying Its Hand in the South China Sea?

Posted on July 27, 2012


China claims a big back yard in the South China Sea. Neighboring nations stake their own claims. Sources: EIA, Middlebury College, National Geographic, CIA Factbook

China is setting up shop on a tiny island in the South China Sea, deploying troops and civilian administrators in a move that is raising tensions in the region and seriously annoying Vietnam and the Philippines.

The move comes on the heels of a conference of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) earlier this month that couldn’t agree on a Code of Conduct to deal with conflicting territorial claims on islands in the region.

China’s new military garrison is on a 2.5 square kilometer patch of land it calls Yongxing in the Paracel Islands chain. According to Ziao Jie, China’s newly appointed mayor of the island’s capital region, Sansha City, the new settlement is meant to “safeguard national sovereignty and security, to strengthen the protection of resources and overall development in the South China Sea.”

Philippine President Benigno Aquino III doesn’t like that at all. He doesn’t recognize Sansha’s founding and has announced plans to buy attack helicopters.

“If someone enters your yard and told you he owns it, will you allow that?” President Aquino asked the Philippines parliament.

Vietnam is equally annoyed. Officials in Hanoi rolled out what they say is a 1904 Qing Dynasty map that makes no claims to sovereignty over the Paracels or the Spratley Islands to the south.

“The Vietnamese are a special race,” museum historian Mai Ngoc Hong told reporters. “We are like a hard constrained spring. Use force on it and it will coil, and watch out when it does.”

Vietnam and the Philippines are the loudest opponents of the new Chinese settlement because Beijing’s Marine Surveillance forces use the island to patrol waters Hanoi and Manila claim as their own.

ASEAN’s diplomatic balance

But what about other ASEAN members, especially those whose economies benefit from hefty Chinese investments?

At the Washington-based Cato Institute, Foreign Policy Studies director Justin Logan says China’s new Sansha settlement could change the diplomatic equation in ASEAN. According to Logan, making territorial pronouncements is one thing; deploying troops and civilian administrators is something entirely different.

“I think that China may be overplaying its hand here,” Logan says. “There are certain countries, obviously Cambodia, and other countries in the region and in ASEAN that have been more or less willing, for a variety of different reasons, to be supportive of China in this context.”

“And I think that this could really put pressure on them to say: ‘Look, we can’t back you up on this. Maybe we will just sort of sit this out or we won’t make a statement on it at all.’ But the idea that they are going to have a diplomatic coalition of the willing saying that this is alright I think becomes really tough to do.”

Cambodia helped scuttle regional unanimity over a Code of Conduct at the ASEAN foreign ministerial in Phnom Penh, contributing to what the International Crisis Group calls a weakness of the multilateral framework that “has also proven ineffective in reducing tensions.”

“Divisions between member states, stemming from different perspectives on the South China Sea and differences in the value each member places on their relations with China, have prevented ASEAN from coming to a consensus on the issue,” the ICG says. “China has worked actively to exploit these divisions, offering preferential treatment to ASEAN members that do not side with its rival claimants.”

But Cambodia sees things differently, insisting that it remains an honest broker.

“Cambodia doesn’t take sides,” Foreign Minister Hor Namhong told VOA’s Say Mony. “Cambodia is the Chair of ASEAN, and we have to make sure that situation remains calm, not to add fuel to fire.”

Washington’s role

Stanford University’s Don Emmerson says the breadth of China’s claim over nearly all of the 3.5-million-square-kilometer sea appears increasingly designed to reduce the role of the U.S. Navy as part of the Obama administration’s “Asia Pivot.”

“One would even suggest that those within the People’s Liberation Army who are among the most vehement nationalists on this issue would like to see the South China Sea actually become a Chinese lake,” Emmerson says.

Cato’s Justin Logan believes Washington is going “a little bit too far into making this a U.S. vs. China competition in the South China Sea.”

“If the United States had a somewhat more distant posture and wasn’t always rushing to assure its friends and allies in the region that we would be on the hook to ensure freedom of navigation,” Logan says, “other countries in the region would be, in fact, more alarmed about China’s behavior.”

“But the idea that they see the United States at the forefront of this effort to constrain China’s ambition in the South China Sea allows them to stand back a little bit and play one side off the other.”


China appoints officers to South China Sea garrison

GMA News – ‎2 hours ago‎
BEIJING – China has appointed military officers at a newly-established garrison in the South China Sea, state media reported Friday, the country’s latest step to bolster claims to disputed islands in the area. The defense ministry announced the

China names military heads of South China Sea city

Zee News – ‎4 hours ago‎
Beijing: China has taken another step in its campaign to claim the world’s most disputed waters by naming two senior military officers to head a garrison in the South China Sea, days after calling the island community the country’s newest city.

Hard to navigate multiple tugs of war

Brisbane Times – ‎6 hours ago‎
Casting the net wide … Chinese fishing ships sail through Meiji reef, in the disputed Spratly Islands, this month. Photo: AP When a fishing boat packed with sign-waving young Chinese activists arrived on July 4 at a disputed island group south of Japan

How to calm the South China Sea

The Australian – ‎6 hours ago‎
THE South China Sea long regarded, together with the Taiwan Strait and the Korean Peninsula, as one of East Asia’s three major flashpoints is making waves again. China’s announcement of a troop deployment to the Paracel Islands follows a month in which

China appoints officers to West Philippine Sea garrison – ‎7 hours ago‎
By Frances Mangosing A fishing boat sails past the Meiji reef off the island province of Hainan in the West Philippine Sea in this photo taken on July 20. AP MANILA, Philippines—China appointed military officers in its garrison in the West Philippine

No Need Yet For UN Peacekeepers — Malacañang

Manila Bulletin – ‎8 hours ago‎
By MADEL R. SABATER and Agence France Presse MANILA, Philippines — Malacañang said on Friday that it sees no need to call in United Nations (UN) peacekeeping forces amid the country’s tension with China, which announced Thursday the appointment of

New Chinese Base Raises Tensions in S. China Sea

Voice of America – ‎8 hours ago‎
STATE DEPARTMENT — China’s move to base troops on a disputed island in the South China Sea has raised concerns about a possible military confrontation in an area where China, Vietnam, Malaysia, Taiwan, Brunei and the Philippines all have competing

New Garrison, Old Troubles in the South China Sea

TIME (blog) – ‎9 hours ago‎
By Kirk Spitzer | July 26, 2012 | + China’s newest military garrison in the contentious South China Sea is largely a political show and won’t significantly raise the threat of armed confrontation in the region. Which is not saying much,

China hardens island base

Bangkok Post – ‎9 hours ago‎
China has appointed military officers at a newly established garrison in the South China Sea, state media reported on Friday, marking the country’s latest step to bolster claims to disputed islands in the area. Chinese soldiers take part in a 2004

Rivals China, Taiwan may pair up on South China Sea project

Asahi Shimbun – ‎9 hours ago‎
By TAKIO MURAKAMI/ Correspondent TAIPEI–Historic rivals China and Taiwan may be edging closer to a possible partnership over territorial rights in the South China Sea and the Spratly (Nansha) Islands, which is alarming other southeast Asian nations

Commentary: US meddling in maritime disputes detrimental to Asia-Pacific peace

Xinhua – ‎9 hours ago‎
BEIJING, July 27 (Xinhua) — The United States has recently stepped into bilateral disputes in the waters surrounding China, criticizing Beijing’s move to establish a city in the South China Sea and lending veiled support to other claimants.

China Names Military Chiefs for Disputed Island City

Voice of America – ‎9 hours ago‎
China announced Thursday that it had appointed two senior military officers to head a garrison in a new city established on a disputed island just days ago. Official media Friday quoted Defense Ministry spokesman Yang Yujun as saying the garrison will

Beijing adopts aggressive stance as hawks gain sway in South China Sea dispute – ‎12 hours ago‎
HONG KONG — China has adopted a more aggressive stance in recent weeks on territorial disputes in the South China Sea as hard-line officials and commentators call on Beijing to take a tougher line with rival claimants. Only on Tragedy in

South China Sea row: US wants collaborative diplomatic process to resolve tension

Economic Times – ‎13 hours ago‎
WASHINGTON: The US supports a collaborative diplomatic process to resolve the South China Sea dispute between China and its neighbours as it is against measures that are seen as potential threats to some in the region, a top American official has said.

South China (West Philippine) Sea: A decades-long source of tension

GMA News – ‎14 hours ago‎
Rival claims to the South China Sea have for decades been a source of tension in the region. Below are key facts on the sea and the competing claims: The South China Sea covers more than 3000000 square kilometers (1200000 square miles) on the western

China appoints major officers for Sansha City garrison

GMA News – ‎17 hours ago‎
China has appointed the major officers of the garrison that will be deployed to its newly formed Sansha City in the disputed Spratly Islands. Defense ministry spokesman Yang Yujun said Senior Colonel Cai Xihong is the commander and Senior Colonel Liao

US concerned over China’s Spratlys garrison plan

Philippine Star – ‎17 hours ago‎
WASHINGTON (AP) — The US is criticizing Chinese plans for a military garrison on an island in the contested South China Sea and says all claimants should resolve their disputes through diplomacy. China Tuesday declared a new municipality on tiny

Sansha military garrison established

China Daily – ‎19 hours ago‎
By Zhao Shengnan and Zhang Yunbi ( China Daily) The Ministry of National Defense on Thursday announced the appointment of major officers to the Sansha military garrison, saying China’s military establishments in its own territory are irrelevant to

Beijing looks for military solution to island dispute

Times of India – ‎19 hours ago‎
BEIJING: China on Thursday said it will have two military garrisons operating in the disputed Sansha islands in South China Sea, one of its army and the other of its navy . The assessment is that the new military establishments mean Beijing is ruling

Establishment of Sansha city within sovereignty

China Daily – ‎20 hours ago‎
By Sansha ( Xinhua) BEIJING – China said Thursday that the establishment of the city of Sansha in the South China Sea is an affair within the country’s sovereignty. “We are willing to reiterate that the establishment of the city of Sansha is a

Sansha Garrison chiefs appointed

China Daily – ‎20 hours ago‎
By Zhang Yunbi and Zhao Shengnan ( The Defense Ministry on July 26 said the chiefs of the Sansha Garrison have been appointed, and the establishment of related bodies on China’s territory “has nothing to do with other countries”.

Australia Urged to Defuse South China Sea Tensions

The Chosun Ilbo – ‎21 hours ago‎
Australia has been urged to do more to help ease tensions in the South China Sea. China and Vietnam disagree about territorial claims, while other countries, including the United States and the Philippines, have also been drawn into the long-running

US concerned over South China Sea garrison plan

The Seattle Times – ‎22 hours ago‎
AP State Department spokeswoman Victoria Nuland says the US is pressing all countries in the region to work on a code of conduct for the South China Sea. China on Tuesday declared a new municipality on tiny Yongxing island – a move that’s opposed by

China’s hard-line stance cause for grave concern

The Daily Yomiuri – ‎Jul 26, 2012‎
We urge China to restrain itself from taking unilateral action and to work to alleviate tension through dialogue with Vietnam and other neighboring countries. China has created the city of “Sansha” to administer the Spratly Islands, the Paracel Islands

China’s hawks gaining sway in South China sea dispute

Reuters UK – ‎Jul 26, 2012‎
By David Lague | HONG KONG (Reuters) – China has adopted a more aggressive stance in recent weeks on territorial disputes in the South China Sea as hard-line officials and commentators call on Beijing to take a tougher line with rival claimants.

Assert sovereignty over disputed islands: DPP

Taipei Times – ‎Jul 26, 2012‎
By Chris Wang / Staff reporter The Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) yesterday urged President Ma Ying-jeou (馬英九) to express Taiwan’s firm position on its sovereignty in the South China Sea after Beijing’s establishment of a military garrison in

Sea of discontent threatens more than Asian unity

The Australian – ‎Jul 26, 2012‎
WHERE is Australia most vulnerable? Some analysts argue we should worry about Australia’s southeast, where the vast proportion of our population and economic activity occurs not far from the coast. Others are concerned about the northwest,

Qing dynasty map shows no China claim in Spratlys

ABS CBN News – ‎Jul 26, 2012‎
HANOI – Vietnam’s National Museum of History displayed on Wednesday a map donated by a local historian that he said proved China had no claim to disputed islands in the South China Sea. The map was donated by Dr. Mai Ngoc Hong who said it was a 1904

Progress ‘makes ASEAN an attractive target’

Jakarta Post – ‎Jul 25, 2012‎
ASEAN’s progress as a grouping has made it an attractive target for external powers, according to its secretary-general Surin Pitsuwan, who warned against escalating tensions over the South China Sea. The ‘projection of power’ could derail ASEAN’s
Posted in: Economy, Politics