U.S. lawmakers blame China over maritime disputes

Posted on September 13, 2012


In this July 21 file photo, Chinese people chat in front of an administration office building for the Xisha, Nansha, Zhongsha islands on Yongxing Island, the government seat of Sansha City off the Hainan province, southern China. Beijing on Aug. 4 summoned an American diplomat to express its dissatisfaction over U.S. criticism of China’s new military garrison in the South China Sea. (AP file photo)

WASHINGTON–U.S. lawmakers on Sept. 12 accused China of bullying its neighbors to press territorial claims in the South China Sea but also raised questions about America’s capacity to police the region.

Three congressional panels this week are scrutinizing what they consider to be the security threat posed by China and its human rights record.

With the U.S. presidential election two months away, Republican contender Mitt Romney has accused Barack Obama of being soft on China, particularly on trade issues, as he has tried to cultivate ties with the emerging superpower. But criticism dished out by members of the House Foreign Relations Committee on Sept. 12 was directed squarely at Beijing.

The committee’s Republican chair, Ileana Ros-Lehtinen, dubbed China a “schoolyard bully towards its maritime neighbors” that aspired to be the dominant power in Asia, controlling vital sea lanes that could be used to choke off commerce and oil shipments. She said the U.S. would stand by its allies, the Philippines and Japan.

“Other global crises must not distract from our vital national interests in the South China Sea and the western Pacific,” she told a hearing addressing the issue.

Top Democrat Howard Berman said the Obama administration has repeatedly made clear to Beijing that the U.S. will not allow China to assert hegemony over the region. He said the U.S. must continue to press China to resolve its claims peacefully.

China and five of its neighbors, including the Philippines and Vietnam, have overlapping claims to several small, but potentially energy-rich areas of the South China Sea, that have become an increasing focus of bickering and confrontation. In July, China upped the ante when it created a city and military garrison on a remote island to strengthen its control over disputed islands.

The United States criticized that as undermining efforts to manage and resolve disputes through diplomacy. That angered China, which says it has no aggressive intent.

The U.S., which remains the world’s predominant military power, says it does not take a position on the competing territorial claims, but has a national security interest in the maintenance of peace and stability in the region. On Sept. 11 it urged “cooler heads to prevail” in a separate island dispute between Japan and China in the East China Sea.

Republican Rep. Mike Kelly questioned the ability of an indebted U.S. to sustain its military presence across the world, and suggested China was now “the toughest guy in the neighborhood” that would call the shots on policy there.

“At some point we better wake up and smell the coffee,” Kelly said. “We have a diminished influence because we really don’t have the ability at times to do what we say we are going to do.”

Democrat Rep. Brad Sherman said U.S. allies needed to bear more of the security burden, as during the Cold War against the Soviet Union.

“Those nations in the Asia-Pacific region, particularly those that have concerns with China’s expansionary claims ought to be devoting a reasonable portion of GDP to their own naval defense,” he said.

On Sept. 13, the House Intelligence Committee will question executives of two major Chinese technology companies as it probes allegations that the firms’ involvement in the U.S. market could pose a national security risk.

Also on Sept. 12, another House panel examined allegations of human organs of religious and political dissidents being harvested by Chinese authorities.

Staunch China critic, Republican Rep. Chris Smith, alleged that kidneys, livers, lungs, hearts and corneas were taken from recently deceased prisoners and that China’s military doctors may also be harvesting organs from live prisoners. He conceded that much of the evidence is circumstantial, but decried the harvesting as a “barbaric practice that must be stopped.”

In an annual human rights review this year, the U.S. State Department cited reports of organ harvesting in China, particularly from practitioners of the banned religious sect, Falun Gong, and the Uighur ethnic minority.

China reportedly plans to abolish organ harvesting of death-row inmates within the next five years.


Posted in: Economy, Politics